How I can assist you in planning and implementing a Franco-American transfer
As a tax lawyer at the Nice Bar, I assist taxpayers and their families with ties and interests in both France and the United States in structuring and anticipating the transfer of their wealth, in collaboration with the notary and their US advisers (estate planning attorney, CPA). I can help you to:
- analyse the applicable civil-law rules with the notary: law governing the estate, matrimonial property regime, forced heirship, wills and trusts;
- analyse the tax rules, calculate the tax due and confirm the French formalities;
- propose anticipation and structuring strategies tailored to your situation;
- coordinate the advisers and strategies, so that a solution that works in France is not penalising in the United States, and vice versa;
- handle the formalities and liaise with the French tax authorities.
Key points at a glance
Civil law
- Several civil laws may apply to a single transfer. An estate, a gift and a matrimonial property regime may be governed by different civil laws depending on the country examining them. Without anticipation, this may lead to contradictions and complications that defeat your initial plans.
- Some mechanisms are not recognised on the other side of the Atlantic. French law does not recognise the trust as such, nor the concept of probate. US law, for its part, does not recognise the French split of ownership (démembrement) or the French rules protecting heirs and the surviving spouse.
Tax
- French investment wrappers and entities may be penalising in the United States. Certain entities or wrappers accumulating passive income (French life insurance, investment funds, French civil companies) may be treated there as passive foreign investment companies (PFIC), with potentially very heavy taxation.
- Assets are not valued in the same way. In the United States, the unrealised gain on an asset is in principle wiped out on death, but not on a gift: a gift could therefore cost a US beneficiary more than an inheritance.
- The same transfer (inheritance or gift) may be taxed in both countries. This is the case, in particular, where the deceased or donor is a US citizen domiciled in France, where a French resident transfers US assets, or where the heir or donee resides in France. The estate and gift tax treaty of 24 November 1978 then applies to eliminate double taxation.
- The treaty can eliminate French taxes. The assets of a deceased person domiciled in the United States are not taxed in France, even if the heirs live there, except for assets located in France. The US real estate of a US citizen domiciled in France is in effect exempt there, thanks to a tax credit equal to the French tax.
- Tax returns remain due in each country, whatever the final tax burden. The treaty has no effect on each country's filing obligations: gift or inheritance tax return in France, specific returns in the United States. Failing to file could also deprive the taxpayer of the treaty tax credit.
1Franco-American inheritance and gifts: which civil law applies?
Civil law does not determine how a transfer will be taxed, but how it will take place: who inherits, in what proportions and in what form.
Several civil laws for a single transfer
A gift is governed by separate laws as to its form, its validity and its effects on death (collation, abatement). For an estate, the law governing the matrimonial property regime first determines what belonged to each spouse; the law governing the estate then designates, in particular, the heirs and their rights.
Caution. The rules set out below are those that a French notary or court would apply. US states would apply their own conflict-of-laws rules, which in principle refer to the law of the place where the property is located for real estate and to the law of the domicile for movable property. The same transfer may therefore be subject to different civil laws depending on the country examining it. Anticipation is therefore essential to avoid any contradiction between France and the United States.
Two distinct sets of conflict-of-laws rules
The law governing the estate
From a French perspective, the EU Succession Regulation No 650/2012 subjects the whole estate to the law of the State of the deceased's last habitual residence (Article 21), unless the deceased chose by will the law of his or her nationality at the time of the choice or at death (Article 22, professio juris).
Where the Regulation designates, for example, the law of a US state, it accepts the renvoi made by that state to the law of the place where real estate is located (Article 34). The French villa of a California resident may thus be governed by French law. From a French perspective, however, a professio juris excludes this renvoi.
The law governing the matrimonial property regime
From a French perspective, the applicable rules depend on the date of the marriage: French case law before 1 September 1992, the Hague Convention of 14 March 1978 until 28 January 2019, and EU Regulation No 2016/1103 since then. Spouses may choose the applicable law from among several connecting factors; failing a choice, the law of their first common habitual residence generally applies.
Under the Hague Convention, which applies to spouses married between 1 September 1992 and 28 January 2019, the applicable law may change automatically, in particular after ten years of residence in another State.
Spouses married under a separate property regime in the State of New York may thus potentially switch automatically to the French statutory community property regime after a certain period of residence in France.
The law governing gifts
From a French perspective, the substantive and formal validity of gifts made since 17 December 2009 is governed by the Rome I Regulation. In principle, the law chosen by the parties applies or, failing that, the law of the place where the real estate is located or the law of the donor's habitual residence.
Other specific instruments may also apply depending on the status of the persons concerned. For example, France would apply the Hague Convention of 13 January 2000 to a gift made by an adult under guardianship, in order to determine the competent authorities and the law applicable to any protection or representation measure.
The law governing the matrimonial property regime may also govern the rules on gifts between spouses or gifts of community property.
Finally, the law governing the estate in principle governs the effects of the gift on the donor's death (in particular the rules on collation, forced heirship and abatement).
As a result, a multitude of different civil laws may apply to one and the same transfer, which requires genuine anticipation and coordination.
The main civil-law differences between France and the United States
French and US civil-law rules stem from two very different legal systems, cultures and traditions. Some legal mechanisms or institutions have no equivalent in the other country and may produce uncertain or even contradictory results.
| Question | France | United States (depending on the state) |
|---|---|---|
| Freedom to dispose of one's assets by gift or will | Limited by the children's forced heirship share (réserve héréditaire, Article 913 of the French Civil Code) | Almost total |
| Rights of the surviving spouse | Statutory heir, forced heir only where there are no descendants | Variable: half of the community property in community property states, elective share in most other states |
| Administration of the estate | Heirs take possession directly, with the involvement of a notary | Probate: court proceedings conducted by an executor, often avoided through a trust |
| Gift | Notarial deed (except for manual gifts), irrevocable, in principle subject to collation and abatement on death | Complete once the donor has irrevocably parted with the asset (completed gift), without formalities for movable property |
| Split of ownership (démembrement) | Usufruct and bare ownership, valued under the statutory tax scale or at their economic value | Not recognised as such (closest equivalent: remainder interest and life interest); the property is brought back into the estate of the donor holding the usufruct (life interest holder) |
| Trust | Unknown in French domestic law; specific tax rules and formalities that may lead to substantial taxation in France | Central planning tool, used in particular to avoid probate and optimise US taxation |
Forced heirship. The typical US will, leaving everything to the surviving spouse and then to the children, may conflict with the French forced heirship principle. From a French perspective, a foreign law governing the estate that does not provide for forced heirship is not in itself contrary to French law. However, the heirs may in principle exercise a compensatory levy (prélèvement compensatoire) on assets located in France where the deceased or one of the heirs is a national or habitual resident of the European Union.
A US citizen resident in the United States who leaves his or her entire estate to the surviving spouse may thus see an heir residing in France claim rights over a French property included in the estate.
Trusts. French law does not recognise the trust as such and recharacterises it according to its own categories, for example as an indirect gift. The assets transferred may therefore be taken into account when calculating the French forced heirship share. Depending on how the trust is drafted and how assets are allocated to beneficiaries, substantial taxation may apply in France.
2Inheritance and gift taxes: how are they levied in France and in the United States?
The first step is to check the territorial scope and the tax rules applicable in each country. Where the same transfer is taxable in both countries, the tax treaty allocates taxing rights and eliminates double taxation (section 3). The US law elements are given for guidance only, subject to confirmation by a US adviser.
Territorial scope
The territorial rules determine when a country may tax a transfer.
| Situation | France (Article 750 ter of the French Tax Code) | United States (federal tax) |
|---|---|---|
| Deceased or donor domiciled in the country or, for the United States, a US citizen | Worldwide assets | Worldwide assets |
| Deceased or donor neither domiciled nor a citizen | Assets located in France, including shares in French real estate companies or receivables from a debtor located in France | Assets located in the United States; for gifts, in principle only real estate and tangible movable property |
| Heir or donee domiciled in France for at least 6 of the last 10 years (continuously or not) | All assets received, whatever the domicile of the deceased or donor and the location of the assets | Not applicable |
Applicable rates
| Beneficiary | France | United States (2026, for guidance) |
|---|---|---|
| Child | Allowance of €100,000 per parent every 15 years; rates from 5% to 45% | Unified exemption of $15 million per donor or deceased, then 40% |
| Spouse | Exempt on death; allowance of €80,724 for gifts | Unlimited exemption if the spouse is a US citizen; otherwise $194,000 per year for gifts |
| Brother, sister, third party | 35% to 45% (brother and sister); 60% (third parties) | Same regime as for a child |
| Deceased non-resident and non-citizen | Depending on the family relationship | Exemption of $60,000 on US assets |
Points of friction between the two tax systems
Each point of friction must be identified before any transaction and then addressed with advisers in both countries. Some of them are discussed below, without claiming to be exhaustive.
Split of ownership: recognised in France, ignored in the United States
Problem In France, bare ownership is in principle valued according to the age of the usufructuary, and the usufruct ends on death without further tax: it is a basic estate planning strategy. US tax law does not have the same concepts of usufruct and bare ownership. It would treat a gift of bare ownership with a reserved usufruct as incomplete: since the donor has retained a right or an economic benefit in the property, the property would be brought back into his or her estate. A US citizen who gives his or her children the bare ownership of a property located in France could thus expose them to double taxation: French gift tax at the time of the gift, then US estate tax on the death of the usufructuary.
Options The first step would be to check whether the donor's estate will remain below the US exemption: the inclusion would then have no cost and could even wipe out the gain on death. Otherwise, a gift of full ownership or another structure could be preferable, to be decided with the US adviser.
Trusts: specific formalities and taxes in France
Problem As soon as a settlor or beneficiary resides in France, or an asset is located there, the trust must be reported every year, and also when certain transactions or changes affecting the trust occur. The assets and income deriving from it are also subject to specific French tax rules.
Options Existing trusts should be reviewed, in particular before any move to France or any transfer to a beneficiary resident in France, in order to decide whether to keep them, distribute their assets or revoke them (section 4).
Investment wrappers: a potential trap for a U.S. person
Problem The US tax authorities would not recognise French tax wrappers. The funds held in a French life insurance contract, like French UCITS funds, would in principle fall within the very penalising US PFIC regime (Passive Foreign Investment Companies). A French SCI or another French company could also, depending on its US classification, be treated as a foreign investment company and heavily taxed. On death, the French levy on life insurance (Article 990 I of the French Tax Code) may also not give rise to a tax credit in the United States, which could result in double taxation.
Options It would in principle be preferable for a U.S. person to avoid French life insurance contracts and funds, and to analyse the US classification of an SCI or a company before it is set up, in collaboration with a US CPA, since a classification election may sometimes be available.
Different valuation rules
Problem In the United States, only assets transferred on death would in principle be revalued (step-up in basis): the donee would keep the donor's cost basis (carryover basis) and, on a sale, would pay tax on the entire gain, calculated from the donor's original purchase price. A gift could therefore cost a US beneficiary more than an inheritance.
Options For a US beneficiary, the cost of a gift should be compared with that of a transfer on death and, where appropriate, preference given to gifts of cash or of assets with little unrealised gain. Such an analysis should be carried out in collaboration with a US CPA and financial adviser.
State taxes
Problem Any estate or inheritance taxes levied at state level are not covered by the Franco-American tax treaty, which only covers federal tax.
Options The states concerned (domicile, location of real estate) should be identified from the outset, and the US adviser should factor these taxes into the planning.
Returns to be filed, even where no tax is due
| Situation | United States (for guidance) | France |
|---|---|---|
| Gift made | Return by the US donor above $19,000 per beneficiary (Form 709) | Return by the donee resident in France (form no. 2735) |
| Gift or inheritance received from abroad | Return by the US beneficiary above $100,000 (Form 3520) | Return in France, even if the treaty exempts the transfer |
| Death | Estate tax return within 9 months (Form 706, or 706-NA for a non-resident holding more than $60,000 of US assets) | Inheritance tax return within 6 months, or 12 months if the death occurs outside France |
| Trust connected with France | Specific returns depending on the case | Event-based and annual returns (forms no. 2181-TRUST-1 and 2181-TRUST-2) |
These obligations remain even where the treaty eliminates the tax. Compliance with them is also a condition for certain treaty tax credits.
3Franco-American tax treaty: which country may tax the transfer?
The treaty does not eliminate tax: for each category of assets, it designates the country that may tax and organises the crediting of tax paid in the other country. Signed on 24 November 1978 and amended by the protocol of 8 December 2004, it covers both estates and gifts, but not taxes that may be levied by individual states.
The domicile of the deceased or donor, the starting point of the treaty
Each country first determines domicile under its domestic law. The French criteria of Article 4 B of the French Tax Code (to which Article 750 ter refers) are alternative: meeting any one of them is sufficient.
In the event of dual domicile, the criteria of Article 4 of the treaty are hierarchical: permanent home, then centre of vital interests, then habitual abode, then citizenship and finally mutual agreement.
Article 4(3) of the treaty protects newcomers: a US citizen who is not a French national and who settles in France remains deemed to be domiciled in the United States only if he or she clearly intends to retain that domicile and has been domiciled in France for less than five of the last seven years. The rule applies symmetrically to a French national settled in the United States. It is not automatic, however, and must be analysed in advance in light of the taxpayer's personal situation.
Treaty rules allocating taxing rights by type of asset
Real estate, including shares in real estate companies, and tangible movable property are taxable in the country where they are located (Articles 5 and 7). Other assets (securities, accounts, receivables) are taxable in the country where the deceased or donor was domiciled (Article 8). The United States, however, retains the right to tax its citizens and persons domiciled there (Article 1(4)): double taxation is then eliminated by a tax credit (Article 12).
| Profile of the deceased or donor | Assets transferred | Country (or countries) taxing | Country granting a tax credit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domiciled in France, not a US citizen | Real estate and tangible movable property in the United States | United States and France | France (credit equal to the US tax, capped) |
| Securities and accounts, including US ones | France only | None | |
| Domiciled in the United States | US assets, securities and accounts | United States only | None |
| Real estate and tangible movable property in France | France and United States | United States (credit equal to the French tax) | |
| US citizen domiciled in France | Real estate and tangible movable property in France | France and United States | United States (credit equal to the French tax) |
| Real estate and tangible movable property in the United States | United States and France | France (credit equal to the French tax: de facto exemption) | |
| Securities and accounts | France and United States | United States (credit equal to the French tax) |
Two effects are worth noting. The assets of a deceased person domiciled in the United States are not taxed in France, even if the heirs reside there, except for assets located in France. The US real estate of a US citizen domiciled in France is in effect exempt in France, provided that it can be shown that the US tax obligations have been met.
Beware of the effective rate rule. An asset exempt in France under the treaty may nevertheless be taken into account in calculating the tax due on the assets that remain taxable there, where French domestic law would have taxed it (Article 12(7)). The exemption may therefore still increase the rate applicable to the other assets.
4Which strategies to secure and optimise a Franco-American transfer?
Before optimising the tax position, it is essential to make sure that the transfer will produce the intended civil-law effects in both countries. A structure that works well in France may be neutral, or even penalising, in the United States, and vice versa. The solutions below are options that are not suited to every situation.
Securing the transfer from a civil-law perspective
Securing the law governing the estate
Issue A US citizen residing in France, or owning property in France, may see his or her estate governed by French civil law and the French forced heirship rules.
Solution A professio juris designating a specific US state could be included in the will. From a French perspective, it would give effect to the US will and exclude the renvoi.
Caution It would not protect assets located in France against a possible compensatory levy under Article 913, paragraph 3, of the French Civil Code, and its effect in the United States should be confirmed by a US adviser.
Securing the law governing the matrimonial property regime
Issue The automatic change of applicable law and the uncertain characterisation of community property regimes expose spouses to an unexpected liquidation of their regime.
Solution An express designation of the law governing the matrimonial property regime, by notarial deed, could be considered as soon as the couple settles in France.
Caution Such a designation is binding on the French courts; its effect in the United States should be confirmed by a US adviser.
Protecting the surviving spouse with care
Issue The "everything to the spouse, then to the children" pattern may, under certain conditions, conflict with forced heirship where French law applies.
Solution The professio juris could remain the main tool. French mechanisms (gift between spouses, reversion of usufruct, advance waiver of the action for abatement) could only be considered on a case-by-case basis, mainly for assets located in France.
Caution These mechanisms might not be fully recognised in the United States, and whether an advance waiver is effective against the compensatory levy has not yet been settled.
Optimising the transfer from a tax perspective
Making gifts before moving to France
Issue Once the family has settled in France, gifts generally become taxable at rates of up to 45% in the direct line, in the absence of planning.
Solution US assets could be given while both donors and donees are domiciled in the United States. The gift would then fall outside French tax and would only use up the US exemption.
Caution The gift should nevertheless be registered in France (form no. 2735) to give it a certain date. For a US donee, the loss of the step-up on death (step-up in basis) should be taken into account.
Securing treaty domicile during the first years
Issue A US citizen who settles in France may become domiciled there and expose his or her worldwide financial assets to French inheritance tax.
Solution Article 4(3) of the treaty could be relied on to retain US domicile, where appropriate secured by a tax ruling, by building a domicile file: home retained in the United States, accounts, US tax returns.
Caution This rule is not automatic: the intention to retain US domicile must be analysed case by case, documented and credible. It would also only concern gift and inheritance taxes, not income tax.
Structuring the ownership of French real estate
Issue For a person domiciled in the United States, French real estate held directly is taxable in France on its full value.
Solution An acquisition through a French SCI financed by a shareholder current account could be considered. Under the treaty, this current account could be taxable only in the United States, the French tax base then being reduced to the net value of the shares.
Caution The benefit disappears if domicile moves to France, and the deductibility of the current account is restricted for French real estate wealth tax (IFI). The French SCI could also give rise to US reporting obligations.
Reviewing trusts before moving to France
Issue A US trust, even a revocable one, falls within the French trust regime as soon as its settlor or one of its beneficiaries becomes resident in France.
Solution Each trust should be reviewed before the move, in order to decide whether to keep it, distribute its assets or revoke it, depending on its usefulness in the United States and its tax cost in France.
Caution Any decision should be coordinated with the US adviser, in particular with regard to probate and pour-over wills.
5Frequently asked questions on Franco-American inheritance
My parents live in the United States and I live in France: will I pay inheritance tax in France?
In principle no, except on their real estate and tangible movable property located in France. Their financial assets and US assets are taxable only in the United States. You will nevertheless have to file a return in France for each estate.
Does the treaty apply to gifts?
Yes. It covers both estates and gifts.
I am a US citizen living in France: where will my estate be taxed?
In both countries, with tax credits that prevent double taxation. Your US real estate is in effect exempt in France; your financial assets bear, in practice, the higher of the two taxes.
Is the French split of ownership (démembrement) recognised in the United States?
In principle no: the property would be brought back into the US estate of the usufructuary. Any gift of bare ownership with a reserved usufruct should therefore be validated in collaboration with your US adviser.
Planning a gift or an inheritance between France and the United States?
For an initial estimate, our gift and inheritance tax simulators and our tax residence audit are available in the Simulators and tools section. To discuss your situation, in coordination with your US advisers: contact@noebarkate-avocat.com.
See also our articles on Franco-Italian and Franco-Monegasque estate planning strategies.
Article updated on 9 November 2026. US amounts are indexed every year. This article is general information based on French law and the Franco-American treaty of 24 November 1978; it does not constitute legal advice. The US law elements are given for guidance only, in conditional terms, and must be confirmed by a US adviser.