How I can assist you with a Franco-Italian transfer
As a tax lawyer at the Nice Bar, I assist families living between France and Italy with the civil-law and tax analysis and planning of their transfer of wealth, working with the relevant professionals in France and Italy.
- I analyse the civil-law rules applicable to each transfer, in collaboration with the notary.
- I analyse the applicable tax rules, calculate the amount of tax due and confirm the tax formalities to be completed.
- I propose strategies for civil-law or tax anticipation and structuring, where circumstances allow, tailored to your specific requirements.
- I coordinate the various parties involved in France and Italy: notaries, bankers, family offices, lawyers, etc.
- I handle the follow-up of formalities and liaise with the French tax authorities.
A parent living in Milan who wishes to pass assets to children settled in Nice, a French couple moving to Italy after their marriage, a flat on the French Riviera inherited by children resident in Italy, a securities portfolio held in Italy given to a grandchild resident in France: a Franco-Italian gift or inheritance requires the coordination of two different civil and tax systems.
Any transfer therefore requires prior civil and tax planning, and often the collaboration of several professionals on both sides of the border. The analysis proceeds in three stages:
- Civil law first. Any transfer, whether by gift or by inheritance, requires first confirming the civil law that will govern it. This analysis requires taking into account the private international law rules of each State; it determines who receives what, and under what substantive and formal conditions.
- Domestic tax rules next. The domestic tax rules applicable in each State must be determined; they may result in the same transfer being taxed twice, both in France and in Italy.
- Finally, the tax treaty. Where relevant, the Franco-Italian tax treaty of 20 December 1990 must be applied; it is in force for estates opened and gifts made since 1 April 1995. It allocates taxing rights between the two States according to different categories of assets and makes it possible to avoid economic double taxation. It also allows certain optimisation strategies, all the more attractive given the substantial gap between French and Italian gift and inheritance tax.
1Franco-Italian inheritance and gifts: which civil law applies?
Civil law does not determine how a transfer will be taxed, but how it will take place. It governs its conditions, its terms and its effects: the rights of the heirs and of the surviving spouse, the calculation of the forced heirship reserve (réserve héréditaire) and of the disposable portion, the option to waive an inheritance, and so on.
These aspects must always be analysed and anticipated, in collaboration with a notary or a local lawyer.
Several civil laws for a single transfer
Several civil laws may apply to a single transfer, and they may change over time:
- for a gift: the law governing its formal requirements, the law governing its substantive requirements, the law governing its effects during the donor’s lifetime (reversion right, successive or residual gifts, etc.) and the law governing its effects on the donor’s death (bringing into account, abatement, etc.);
- for an inheritance: if the deceased was married, it is first necessary to determine the law applicable to their matrimonial property regime, which is liquidated as a result of the death, then the law applicable to the estate itself and to the formalities of the transfer.
Harmonised rules between France and Italy
Certain civil conflict-of-laws rules have been harmonised by European regulations and international conventions applicable in both France and Italy:
the Rome I Regulation of 17 June 2008 determines the law applicable to the formal and substantive validity of a gift made since 17 December 2009;
the EU Succession Regulation No. 650/2012 determines the law applicable to an estate and to the succession effects of a gift, for deaths occurring since 17 August 2015;
the Matrimonial Property Regimes Regulation 2016/1103 of 24 June 2016 determines the law applicable to the matrimonial property regime of spouses married since 29 January 2019, or who have designated the applicable law since that date;
for spouses married between 1 September 1992 and 28 January 2019, France applies the Hague Convention of 14 March 1978, to which Italy is not a party: the two countries may then designate two different laws for the matrimonial property regime of the same couple;
the Washington Convention of 1973 introduced into French and Italian law a specific form of will, the “international will”, recognised in each signatory State.
Note that harmonisation only concerns the rules for determining the civil law applicable to a gift, an estate or a matrimonial property regime, and not the content of those laws. These rules refer to different connecting factors, in particular:
for gifts: the law chosen by the parties or, failing that, the law of the donor’s habitual residence, with the law of the place where the deed is executed potentially governing its form and the law of the place where the property is located prevailing for real estate;
for matrimonial property regimes: the law chosen by the spouses (that of the residence or nationality of one of them) or, failing that, the law of their first common habitual residence or of their common nationality;
for inheritance: the law of the deceased’s last habitual residence, a civil-law concept distinct from tax domicile, or the law of their nationality if they made a choice of law (professio juris) by will.
Thus, without anticipation and harmonisation, an Italian national may have made gifts to their children during their lifetime governed by Italian civil law, married and lived in Switzerland under a matrimonial property regime governed by Swiss civil law, moved to France, died there, and had their estate governed by French civil law.
Anticipating the applicable civil law helps avoid certain contradictions and complications arising from the application of different laws, which may defeat your expectations (as regards the transfer to your children, the protection of the surviving spouse, etc.).
The main civil-law differences between France and Italy
Once the applicable law has been determined, its content may significantly change the outcome of the transfer. Two main distinctions should be borne in mind (Italian law for guidance only):
- Rights and protection of heirs: both legal systems protect children through a reserved share, with different proportions. French law allows several agreements anticipating the estate (gift-partition or donation-partage, advance waiver of the action for abatement), which Italian law in principle prohibits; an infringement of the reserved share is settled in France by a cash compensation payment, and in Italy traditionally by abatement in kind, now refocused on monetary compensation (to be confirmed).
- Rights and protection of the surviving spouse: in France, the spouse is a forced heir only where there are no descendants, but may be extensively protected by the deceased’s own arrangements (gift to the last survivor, universal community with full allocation to the survivor); in Italy, the spouse is always a forced heir and enjoys a right of occupation of the family home, but these contractual protection tools would in principle be prohibited or limited there.
Thus, the main French tools for protecting a spouse (gift to the last survivor, full allocation of the community property) may lose their effectiveness if Italian law applies, while the spouse’s reserved share under Italian law reduces the portion that can be freely disposed of in favour of children or third parties.
Once the applicable civil rules have been established, the tax treatment of the transfer must be anticipated.
Note that there is not necessarily any correlation between the civil law and the tax rules applicable to the same transfer: an estate may be governed by Italian succession law and be subject to French taxation.
2Inheritance and gift tax: how are transfers taxed in France and Italy?
It is first necessary to check the territorial scope rules of each State’s gift and inheritance tax, and then, where applicable, to calculate the tax due in each of them.
Territorial scope rules
| Situation of the deceased or donor, heir or donee | France (Article 750 ter of the French Tax Code (CGI)) | Italy (for guidance only) |
|---|---|---|
| Donor or deceased domiciled in the State | All assets taxed, in France and abroad | All assets taxed, in Italy and abroad |
| Donor or deceased not domiciled in the State | Assets located in France only (unless the beneficiary is domiciled in France, next row) | Assets located in Italy only |
| Beneficiary domiciled in the State | All assets received, if domiciled there for at least six of the last ten years | No criterion based on the beneficiary’s domicile |
Applicable rates
Gift and inheritance tax is calculated as follows in France and in Italy.
| Beneficiary | France | Italy (for guidance only) |
|---|---|---|
| Spouse | Exempt on inheritance; gifts taxed at 5% to 45% after an allowance of €80,724 | 4% above €1,000,000 |
| Child | 5% to 45% after an allowance of €100,000 per parent | 4% above €1,000,000 per child |
| Brother or sister | 35% then 45% after an allowance of €15,932 | 6% above €100,000 |
| Other persons | 55% or 60% | 6% or 8% with no allowance |
Except, in particular, for an inheritance passing to the surviving spouse, which is exempt in France but not in Italy, Italian taxation remains significantly more advantageous in most other transfer scenarios.
The Italian rules are given for guidance only and must be confirmed by an Italian notary or adviser.
Since each country first applies its own rules, the same transfer often results in double taxation. For example, a parent whose tax domicile is in Italy who makes a gift to a child domiciled in France for at least six of the last ten years would be taxed in both countries.
The Franco-Italian tax treaty of 20 December 1990, one of the few French treaties covering both gifts and inheritance, remedies this.
3Franco-Italian tax treaty: which country can tax the transfer?
The treaty does not eliminate the tax: for each category of assets, it designates the State that may tax and, where applicable, the State that must eliminate double taxation.
The domicile of the deceased or donor: the starting point of the treaty
The treaty applies where the deceased or the donor was domiciled in France or in Italy at the time of the transfer. This domicile is first assessed under the domestic law of each State:
| France (Article 4 B CGI) | Italy (Article 2 of the TUIR, for guidance only) | |
|---|---|---|
| Criteria | A person is domiciled in France if they meet any of the following criteria: home or principal place of stay in France; main professional activity carried on in France; centre of economic interests in France | A person is resident in Italy if, for the greater part of the year (183 days), they have their civil-law residence or their domicile (centre of their personal and family relationships) there, or are physically present there |
| Specific features | Alternative criteria: one is sufficient | Registration in the Italian population register creates a presumption of residence, unless proven otherwise |
The same person may therefore be regarded as domiciled in both States. The treaty rules for resolving this conflict are set out below.
Confirming and securing tax domicile
The treaty relies on the domicile of the deceased or the donor. However, a person who divides their life between the two countries may be regarded as domiciled in both France and Italy under their domestic laws.
Moreover, the treaty only regards as domiciled in a State a person who is taxed there on their entire estate (Art. 4 § 1).
Caution: a person taxed only on assets located in one State, such as a new resident who has opted for the Italian flat-tax regime for new residents (taxed only on their Italian assets), should therefore not be regarded as domiciled in Italy within the meaning of the treaty. The donor would then lose the protection of the treaty and be exposed to French taxation of their gift, in particular if the donee resides in France.
In the event of dual domicile, the treaty resolves the conflict by applying the following criteria in turn:
| Criterion (Art. 4 of the treaty) | Definition |
|---|---|
| 1. Permanent home | Accommodation available to the person on a lasting basis, whether owned or rented, and not for a short stay |
| 2. Centre of vital interests | Country with which personal ties (family, social life) and economic ties (activity, assets, asset management) are closest |
| 3. Habitual abode | Country where the person stays most often, assessed over a significant period |
| 4. Nationality | Country of which the person is a national, if they are a national of only one of the two |
| 5. Mutual agreement | Failing that, the two tax authorities decide by mutual agreement |
The specific five-year rule, for inheritance only. The protocol to the treaty departs from these criteria. It maintains domicile in the country of nationality of a person who is a national of that country only, who is regarded as domiciled in both countries under their domestic laws, who was domiciled in the other country for less than five years in total during the seven years preceding their death, and who clearly intended to retain their domicile there.
For example, a French national who does not hold Italian nationality, who has a domicile in Italy and retains a home in France is regarded as resident in both countries under their domestic tax laws. He moves to Italy and dies there four years later. He will still be regarded as domiciled in France within the meaning of the treaty if it is established that he clearly intended to retain his domicile in France: keeping his address and his home, registration on local registers, bills paid at that address, etc.
Our recommendation. Domicile is secured through prior analysis and by gathering sufficient evidence in the event of a tax audit. A robust evidence file should be built from the time of relocation: title deed or lease, count of days of presence, administrative registrations (Italian population register or register of Italians resident abroad, electoral rolls, social security), children’s schooling, location of accounts and of asset management, consistent tax returns in both countries and, where applicable, written documents expressing the intention to settle or to return.
Treaty rules allocating taxing rights by type of asset
| Type of asset | State with taxing rights | State that eliminates double taxation |
|---|---|---|
| Real estate | State where the property is located, and State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Arts. 5 and 11) | State of domicile of the deceased or donor, by crediting the tax paid in the State where the asset is located (Art. 11) |
| Shares in a company whose assets consist mainly of French real estate | France, and State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Arts. 5 § 3 and 11) | State of domicile of the deceased or donor, by crediting the tax paid in the State where the asset is located (Art. 11) |
| Business assets | State of the permanent establishment, and State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Arts. 6 and 11) | State of domicile of the deceased or donor, by crediting the tax paid in the State where the asset is located (Art. 11) |
| Shares and other securities | State of the issuing company, and State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Arts. 8 and 11) | State of domicile of the deceased or donor, by crediting the tax paid in the State where the asset is located (Art. 11) |
| Receivables (for example a shareholder current account) | State of domicile of the debtor, and State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Arts. 8 and 11) | State of domicile of the deceased or donor, by crediting the tax paid in the State where the asset is located (Art. 11) |
| Non-negotiable company shares (SARL, société civile), on our reading | State of domicile of the deceased or donor only (Art. 9) | Not applicable |
| Furniture, works of art, vehicles, sums of money given | State of domicile of the deceased or donor only (Art. 9) | Not applicable |
As a result, a transfer made by a donor or deceased domiciled in France will generally bear total tax equal to the amount of French tax (after deduction of any Italian tax levied on assets located in Italy).
Several points concerning the application of the tax treaty:
- Disputed classifications. The location of certain assets is a matter of debate between the two tax authorities. France thus attaches bank accounts to the State of the bank (Art. 8), whereas part of Italian practice attaches them to the State of domicile (Art. 9).
- The French six-year rule is neutralised. According to the French tax authorities (BOI-ENR-DMTG-10-10-30, § 420), the treaty takes into account only the domicile of the deceased or donor and overrides Article 750 ter, 3° CGI. Where the parent is domiciled in Italy, France taxes only the assets that the treaty allocates to it, even if the beneficiary, whether heir or donee, lives in France. A ministerial answer of 8 February 2011 (No. 92034) and part of the legal commentary nevertheless adopt a more restrictive reading, which limits this neutralisation to Article 9 assets, i.e. assets that fall solely within the country of domicile (furniture, sums of money given).
- Elimination of double taxation and the effective rate (Article 11). The State of domicile deducts from its tax the tax paid in the other State on the assets that the latter may tax, up to the amount of its own tax attributable to those same assets. The other State may, in setting its rate, take into account all the assets it could have taxed under its domestic law: France thus applies to the assets it may tax a rate calculated on everything received by an heir domiciled in France (as if the treaty did not exist).
- Reporting obligations remain. The allocation of taxing rights does not remove any of the reporting obligations provided for by the domestic law of each State, which must be fulfilled with the help of a local professional.
4What strategies can secure and optimise a Franco-Italian transfer?
Before optimising the tax position, it must be ensured that the transfer will produce the intended civil-law effects in both countries. These strategies are to be implemented with the French notary and, where applicable, an Italian notary. The main ones are set out below. Each requires a genuine estate planning rationale: a transaction motivated mainly by the tax advantage is exposed to the abuse of law doctrine.
Securing the transfer from a civil-law perspective
Securing the law applicable to the estate
Issue The law governing the estate depends on the deceased’s last habitual residence, a factual assessment that may be disputed where the family lives between the two countries. Depending on the law applied, the children’s reserved share, the spouse’s rights and the validity of earlier gifts are not the same.
Solution Anyone may make a choice of law (professio juris) by will in favour of the law of their nationality. This choice removes uncertainty and makes it possible to select the law best suited to the family’s objectives, for example French law for a French national living in Italy who wishes to protect their spouse by a gift to the last survivor. If the estate includes assets located in Italy, it should be checked beforehand with an Italian notary that this choice and the deeds flowing from it can be fully recognised and enforced in Italy.
Securing the law applicable to the matrimonial property regime
Issue The matrimonial property regime is liquidated before the estate and determines what each spouse is entitled to. For couples married before 2019, France and Italy may apply two different laws and, from a French perspective, the applicable law may have changed automatically if the spouses changed residence.
Solution Identify the applicable law or laws and then, if necessary, expressly designate the law governing the regime or adapt the marriage contract, in particular to protect the surviving spouse, in collaboration with a French or Italian notary.
Optimising the transfer from a tax perspective
Securing a manual gift for tax purposes
Issue In France, a manual gift (don manuel) becomes taxable when it is disclosed to the tax authorities. Take the example of an Italian national who gives their child, an Italian resident, sums held in an account in Italy: no French tax then applies, since neither the donor nor the beneficiary is domiciled in France and the asset is not located there. Several years later, the donor moves to France and dies there. The gift, disclosed in the French inheritance tax return, may then be taxed in France. Yet the treaty reserves the taxation of this gift to Italy if the donor was domiciled there at the time of the gift, provided that its date can be established.
Solution Declare the manual gift in France (form No. 2735) before the donor or donee transfers their residence to France, in order to give it a certain date. Unlike France, where a manual gift may be made without a notarial deed, Italian law would in principle require a notarial deed for any gift that is not of modest value (to be confirmed with an Italian notary).
Making gifts during the first year of Italian residence, before opting for the flat-tax regime
Issue The Italian flat-tax regime for new residents (€300,000 per year since 2026) limits Italian gift and inheritance tax to Italian assets only. However, the treaty does not regard as domiciled in Italy a person taxed only on their Italian assets: while the option is in force, the family may lose the benefit of the treaty, and France may regain the right to tax assets received by children living in France.
Solution A French national moving to Italy may make their gifts during a first year under the ordinary Italian regime, and then opt for the flat-tax regime for subsequent years. The gifts then benefit from the treaty and from the Italian rates.
Caution The French domicile must be clearly severed. Ordinary Italian income tax for that first year must be weighed against the expected tax saving. The flat-tax regime protects income, but not necessarily the transfer: how it interacts with the 1990 treaty has not yet been settled by the courts.
Transferring sums of money from the right bank account
Issue France and Italy may classify a bank account differently for the purposes of the treaty:
- for France, it is a receivable from a bank, taxable in the State where the bank is domiciled (Article 8) and in the State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Article 11);
- for part of Italian practice, it is a sum of money, taxable solely in the State of domicile of the deceased or donor (Article 9).
Where a person domiciled in Italy gives sums held in a French bank account, those sums are therefore at risk of being taxed both in France, where the bank is domiciled, and in Italy, where the donor is domiciled, without a credit for the French tax.
Solution Repatriate cash to Italian accounts before any transfer.
Caution Only cash moves with the account: shares in French companies held in an Italian account remain French assets.
Borrowing against French real estate
Issue An Italian resident who owns real estate in France will be taxed in France on its value, at the French rates.
Solution The treaty deducts from the value of real estate the debts specifically secured on it, whatever the use of the funds. An Italian resident who finances their residence in Italy with a loan secured on their flat in Nice reduces the taxable base in France accordingly.
Caution The debt must still exist at the time of death: according to the tax authorities, where a loan is covered by death insurance, neither the debt nor the capital paid by the insurer is taken into account in the estate. The cost of the loan and the mortgage must be weighed against the expected saving, and any French real estate wealth tax (IFI) implications must also be anticipated.
Structuring the ownership of French real estate
Issue Shares in a company whose assets consist mainly of French real estate remain taxable in France, even if the donor or deceased is not domiciled in France: the treaty treats them as French real estate (as regards France only).
Solution Outside this case, the treaty does not cover real estate held through a company: it is the company’s shares that are transferred, and they follow their own rules. Shares in an Italian company are securities located in Italy, whose transfer by an Italian resident is not taxable in France. The same would apply, on our reading, to non-negotiable company shares (SARL, société civile), which are not securities and are therefore taxable only in the country of domicile. An Italian company whose French real estate represents less than half of its assets can thus take the property outside the scope of French tax. Financing must follow the same logic: a current account advance made to a French company is a receivable from a French debtor, taxable in France. It is preferable to capitalise it, through a capital increase, or to route the financing through the Italian company.
Caution The proportion of French real estate is assessed on the date of the transfer and may change with the value of the assets. Companies holding real estate in France are moreover in principle liable to an annual tax of 3% of its value, unless they file the returns that allow them to be exempt. Finally, the Italian company must have economic substance and a justification other than tax.
Allocating assets among the heirs
Issue Where the deceased or donor resides in Italy, France taxes only the assets that the treaty allocates to it, i.e. those located in France. But where the beneficiary is domiciled in France (and has been for at least six of the last ten years), France applies a rate calculated on everything they receive, including Italian assets that it cannot tax. A modest-value asset located in France may thus bear a high overall tax rate (up to 45% in the direct line).
Solution By will or gift-partition (donation-partage), allocate the assets taxable in France to the heir resident in Italy and the Italian assets to the one resident in France. The heir or donee resident in France then receives no asset taxable in France, provided that the deceased or donor is domiciled in Italy.
Caution Concentrating the French assets on a single heir deprives them of the other heirs’ allowances: the allocation must be modelled and remain compatible with the reserved share.
5Frequently asked questions on Franco-Italian inheritance
My father lives in Italy and I live in France: will I pay inheritance tax in France?
In principle, only on the assets that the treaty allocates to France (real estate located in France, shares in companies whose assets consist mainly of French real estate, shares in French companies, accounts with French banks), at a rate that takes into account everything you receive. Italy, as the State of your father’s domicile, taxes the entire estate and deducts the tax paid in France on the French assets.
I am an Italian resident and I own a flat in Nice: who will tax its transfer?
France, the country where the property is located. Italy, as the State of your domicile, will also tax the transfer, but will deduct the French tax from its own tax, up to the amount of Italian tax attributable to that flat. The taxable value in France can be reduced, in particular, by borrowing secured on the property.
Does the Italian flat-tax regime for new residents exempt my estate?
It limits Italian tax to assets located in Italy, but it may deprive the family of the benefit of the treaty: France could then tax the assets received by your children living in France.
Does the Franco-Italian treaty apply to gifts?
Yes, unlike most tax treaties concluded by France, which cover inheritance only.
Is an Italian notary needed?
Yes, whenever Italian real estate is involved, and in most cases for any gift governed by Italian civil law. We coordinate our work with them.
Planning a gift or an inheritance between France and Italy?
For an initial estimate, our gift and inheritance tax simulators and our tax residence audit are available in the Simulators and tools section. To discuss your situation: contact@noebarkate-avocat.com.
Article updated on 2 November 2026. General information based on French law and the Franco-Italian treaty of 20 December 1990, which does not constitute legal advice. The Italian law elements are given for guidance only.